Papa Jim’s Ice Cream, a beloved local spot, delights every visitor with sweet happiness! With locations in Troy and Palmyra (Lake Monticello), this family-friendly shop has been delighting the community with its creamy, grass-fed dairy ice cream and inventive flavors made with fresh, natural mix-ins.
What to Expect
Two Convenient Locations – Visit their original shop in Troy (open March through October) or their Lake Monticello location, open daily from noon to 9 PM.
Creative & Classic Flavors – From timeless favorites like vanilla and chocolate to rotating seasonal flavors and Italian ice, there’s always something new to try.
Ice Cream Cakes & Treats – Perfect for birthdays, parties, or just because! Papa Jim’s offers beautifully crafted ice cream cakes that taste as good as they look.
Family-Friendly Fun – With cheerful service and a laid-back, welcoming atmosphere, it’s the perfect spot for family outings, date nights, or sweet pit stops after a day in town.
